20% off your first order. Save up to $1,000/€1,000. Ends 30 Nov 2024. Get a quote

Get instant quote

3D printed injection molds: Materials compared

We compare critically two industrial 3D printing materials used for low-run injection mold manufacturing.

3D printed Injection Molds: Materials Compared

Introduction

Using 3D printing processes to create end-use tooling is becoming more and more common as the capabilities of the technologies increase.

In this article we focus in a specific tooling application: low-run injection molding. An extensive review of the applications of 3D printing in this area can be found here. In this article, we compare two popular materials that are currently used in the industry for manufacturing injection molds.

Injection molding is a highly demanding application for a 3D printed material, as the molds have to withstand the processing forces at an elevated temperature and retain their dimensional accuracy over multiple runs. 3D printed injection molds are best suited for:

Fast turnaround times (1-2 week opposed to 5-7 weeks).
Applications where production quantities are low (50 - 100 parts).
Mold designs where changes or iterations are probable.
Parts that are relatively small (less than 150 mm).

Low-run injection mold 3D printed with SLA in DSM Somos PreFORM.

Courtesy: Wehl & Partner Iberica

Material requirements for mold making

A 3D printing material suitable for manufacturing injection molds must have:

  • High stiffness: The molds must retain their good dimensional accuracy over multiple runs and withstand the high pressures during material injection without deforming.
  • High-temperature resistance: A high heat deflection temperature (HDT) is crucial, not only to ensure that the mold will not fail during material injection but also to enable more precise control of the process.
  • High level of detail: Injection molds must have high dimensional accuracy and a smooth surface. Highly accurate molds will produce highly accurate parts.

The two 3D printing processes that are able to produce highly accurate and smooth parts (without extensive post-processing) are Material Jetting and Stereolithography (SLA). While Material Jetting is an industrial process exclusively, both desktop and industrial SLA systems exist. The available materials and production capabilities of desktop SLA 3D printers are not viable for high-end production though, so they will not be discussed here.

In this article we focus on two materials that are proven to be suitable of manufacturing low-run injection mold in an industrial environment: the Digital ABS plus for Material Jetting by Stratasys and the Somos PreFORM for SLA by DSM.

Disclaimer: the material properties listed below are provided by the manufacturers and correspond to parts that have undertaken the optimal thermal post-curing process.

Low-run injection mold 3D printed with Material Jetting in Stratasys Digital ABS Plus.

Courtesy: Promolding

Material Comparison

Mechanical properties - Stiffness

Somos PerFORM has a very high tensile and flexural strength, not only when compared to Digital ABS, but also among all other industrial 3D printing materials (for example SLS nylon). However, it is more brittle (low elongation at break) and has a lower impact strength. For mold manufacturing, the mechanical properties of Somos PerFORM are preferable, as a high stiffness and strength are the main requirements.

Digital ABS Plus Somos PerFORM
Tensile strength 55 - 60 MPa 80 MPa
Tensile modulus 2600 - 3000 MPa 9800 MPa
Elongation at break 25 - 40 % 1.2 %
Flexural strength 65 - 75 MPa 146 MPa
Flexural modulus 1700 - 2200 MPa 9030 MPa
Izod impact (notched) 90 - 115 J/m 20 J/m
Hardness (shore D) 85 - 87 93

Thermal properties - Temperature resistance

Heat Deflection Temperature (HDT) indicates the temperature at which a polymer deforms under a certain load. Glass Transition Temperature (Tg) is the temperature region where the thermoset material transitions from a solid “glassy” state to a more pliable “rubbery” state. For injection molding applications, high values of both HDT and Tg are preferable, so Somos PerFORM again outperforms Digital ABS.

Digital ABS Plus Somos PerFORM
HDT (@ 0.46 MPa) * 92 - 95°C 268°C
Glass Transition Temperature (Tg) 47 - 53°C 81°C
*: after thermal post processing

3D printing process - Level of detail

Digital ABS and Somos PerFORM are used in different 3D printing processes. The capabilities of a typical Material Jetting and of a typical industrial SLA system are outlined in the table below. Both technologies can produce very smooth parts with intricate details and require little post-processing. Digital ABS has a small advantage over Somos PerFORM in regards of level of detail, as Material Jetting has the highest dimensional accuracy among all 3D printing technologies (with SLA at a close second).

Digital ABS Plus Somos PerFORM
Process Material Jetting Industrial SLA
Typical dimensional accuracy ± 0.1% (lower limit of ± 0.05 mm) ± 0.15% (lower limit ± 0.05 mm)
Minimum Feature Size 0.05 mm 0.10 mm
Minimum Wall Thickness 0.6 mm 0.8 mm
Minimum Layer Height 14 - 16 microns 25 - 50 microns

Production Capabilities

Both Digital ABS and Somos PerFORM have been used in industrial settings to produce low-run injection molds. The table below summarises the number of parts that a single mold can produces using materials that are considered “easy” and “difficult” to mold (PP and glass fiber filled PA respectively).

The differences in mechanical and thermal properties of the two materials have an impact on the total number of parts a mold can produce. Under normal opperating condition (after the first 3-4 runs), the 3D printed mold will reach a temperature of approximately 120oC, as it is heated from the melted material. Good thermal stabillity is crucial for minimizing the deterioration of the mold. The PA GF test samples of the image bellow were produced using identical mold designs that 3D printed in the two materials (both show the part produced after the 10th run). The quallity of the part produced with the Digtal ABS mold is much lower, as the mold has started to overheat and deteriorate, while the Somos PerFORM mold was still stable.

Digital ABS Plus † Somos PerFORM ‡
Parts in "easy" material * 50 - 100 100 - 200
Parts in "difficult" material ** 5 - 30 30 - 50

* Polypropylene (PP) ** Glass fiber filled polyamide (PA GF) † Source: Promolding ‡ Source: Wehl & Partner

Left: 3D printed mold in Somos PerFORM. Right: Glass filed polyamide parts produced in identical Somos PerFORM (left) and Digtal ABS (right) molds after 10 runs (source: InterPRO)

Summary & Conclusions

Injection molding is a very demanding tooling application: the material must have both high stiffness and must be able to operate at elevated temperatures.

Material Jetting and SLA are the only 3D printing process that can produce parts with the dimensional accuracy and surface finish required for industrial applications. We compared two materials (one for each process) that are used to manufacture 3D printed low-run injection molds.

Even though Digital ABS plus is an excellent material for most functional applications, the higher stiffness and the superior thermal properties of Somos PerFORM make it more suitable for mold making. This is evident by the number of parts each mold manufactured with the two material can produce.

Want to compare prices and lead times for 3D printed mold in your area?

See Digital ABS prices See Somos Perform prices

Rules of Thumb

  • If very high accuracy and a smooth surface finish are required, Material Jetting and SLA are the most suitable 3D printing processes for mold making.
  • To retain their accuracy over multiple runs, 3D printing materials for manufacturing injection molds must have a high stiffness.
  • A high HDT enables the use of higher mold temperatures during processing.

More resources for engineers

Which plastics can be CNC machined?

Read article

When to use titanium vs. aluminum in manufacturing

Read article

The best heat-resistant plastics

Read article

Nylon vs. polyamides: how are they used in manufacturing?

Read article

Manufacturing with polyethylene vs. polypropylene

Read article

When to use resin in 3D printing

Read article

What is TPU and when should you use it?

Read article
Material CNC Milling PMMA 01 hr

Manufacturing with polycarbonate vs acrylic

Read article
iStock-1319654806

A guide to heat treatments and tempers

Read article

3D printing with PLA vs. PETG: What's the difference?

Read article

3D printing with PLA vs. PLA+: What's the difference?

Read article

What is nylon and what are its material properties?

Read article

Which plastics can be CNC machined?

Plastics have become a go-to material for many industries because they are versatile, affordable, and lightweight. CNC machining, while traditionally used for metals, is also a great manufacturing option for producing plastic components. But not all plastics are created equal. In this article, we’ll explore which plastics can be CNC machined, their benefits, design considerations, and how to select the right plastic for your next project.

Read article

When to use titanium vs. aluminum in manufacturing

Great parts are built from the ground up—starting with the right material. So are you ready to test your metal? Titanium and aluminum are two of the most commonly used metals in manufacturing, each with distinct properties and advantages. This guide will help you understand the differences between them and when to use each in your manufacturing process.

Read article

The best heat-resistant plastics

Some plastics operate best under high temperatures. Compare the various properties of thermoplastics, thermosets, and elastomers – as well as their many applications – so you can make an informed choice for your parts.

Read article

Nylon vs. polyamides: how are they used in manufacturing?

Nylon and polyamides are used in manufacturing when engineers require materials that provide mechanical strength, chemical resistance, and versatility. But are polyamides and nylon the same?

Read article

Manufacturing with polyethylene vs. polypropylene

If you’re considering using polypropylene or polyethylene, read up on when to choose each material and the suitability of each for various manufacturing methods.

Read article

When to use resin in 3D printing

There are many great benefits of 3D printing with resin. Find out when to choose this manufacturing method and what to consider before you start your project.

Read article

What is TPU and when should you use it?

Get to know more about thermoplastic polyurethane (TPU) as a manufacturing material. Used for a broad range of applications, TPU’s unique properties make it ideal for both industrial parts and consumer goods.

Read article
Material CNC Milling PMMA 01 hr

Manufacturing with polycarbonate vs acrylic

Polycarbonate and acrylic are two popular materials known for their transparency and versatility. They share many similarities, but their key differences are important to know when choosing a material to create your parts.

Read article
iStock-1319654806

A guide to heat treatments and tempers

Choosing the right heat treatment or temper is one of the most important factors in creating a part that is optimized for specific applications or engineering challenges.

Read article

3D printing with PLA vs. PETG: What's the difference?

Learn the benefits of PLA and PETG, when you should use one instead of the other, post-processing techniques that work for both materials, and more.

Read article

3D printing with PLA vs. PLA+: What's the difference?

Learn the benefits of PLA and PLA+, when you should use one instead of the other, post-processing techniques that work for both materials, and more

Read article

What is nylon and what are its material properties?

Nylon, also known as polyamide (PA) is a synthetic polymer with high tensile strength, excellent resistance to wear and abrasion, and a low coefficient of friction. Here’s how it’s used in manufacturing and engineering applications.

Read article

Show more

Show less

Ready to transform your CAD file into a custom part? Upload your designs for a free, instant quote.

Get an instant quote